Best Toilet Seat


Choosing a toilet seat may not seem like a big deal until you start looking and see just how many features they can have. With today’s advanced technology toilet seats can offer options like personalized cleansing to cool nightlights built right into the seat.

With all of these options available, it might be a lot easier to choose a toilet seat if you have a guide you can refer to that will tell you about all these options as well as introducing you to three of the top rated toilet seats on the market.

These three models are from well-known companies that are known for quality, variety, and durability. Take a look at the reviews on these three choices below and see which one fits your specific toilet seat needs. We also have a buying guide that will list features to look for, options available and more so you know exactly what you are looking at as you are shopping around.

Best Toilet Seat Reviews

1. Bath Royale

Premium Elongated Toilet Seat

5/5 Product Rating
The Bath Royale Elongated seat for toilets is the perfect seat replacement for your existing seat. This versatile seat fits every brand of toilet including Toto, American Standard, Kohler, and others.
It will also fit your toilets with non-standard mounting hole spacing that is 4 inches to 7 inches long. Make sure you measure your toilet hole spacing before purchasing a seat to ensure it will fit. The soft-close lid prevents the seat lid from slamming down and pinching fingers or cracking the toilet. The self-closing ability of the Bath Royale elongated toilet seat will be perfect for those with back problems, the elderly, and children who may have trouble lowering the lid slowly on their own.

Another great feature of this toilet seat is that it is very easy to keep clean. The quick release works with just one touch and allows you to remove the seat quickly so you can thoroughly clean it. Bath Royale’s toilet seat carries a two-year warranty and lasts much longer than molded wood, vinyl covered, and painted wood seats. Weight rating is 400 pounds and it comes with 4 bumpers that are non-slip and help distribute the user’s weight evenly.

2. Bemis

Elongated Plastic Toilet Seat

4.9/5 Product Rating
The Bemis plastic toilet seat is made from durable plastic that will last a long time with proper usage. It will fit all brands of elongated toilets in Canada and The United States. Users love the hospitality-grade plastic that is not flimsy and cheap feeling. The STA-TAAITE fastening system is commercial grade and never loosens.

Installation is super easy. The 4 bumpers help distribute the user’s weight evenly so there is no worry about the seat sliding to the side during use. The seat can be removed easily for deep cleaning and does not require any special skills to install it or remove it when you want to deep clean the toilet.

3. Mayfair

Molded Wood Toilet Seat w/ Whisper Close Lid

4.8/5 Product Rating
If you are looking for a toilet seat that is easy to keep clean, installs easily, and removes quickly for deep cleaning, look no further than the Mayfair molded wood toilet seat. The whisper close lid closes with just a tap without slamming down and endangering little fingers or cracking the toilet.

The Mayfair toilet seat fits all round toilets in both Canada and the United States. It has been made in America using eco-friendly processes and materials. The molded wood seat has a glossy finish that is scratch and chip resistant. The fastening system Mayfair uses is the STA-TITE fastening system that is super easy to install and never loosens up. You’ll have no more worries about seats that shift when you are trying to use the bathroom.

Summary of Best Toilet Seats

A good quality toilet seat is a desired thing among homeowners and renters everywhere. No one wants to sit on a toilet that has a seat that shifts, cracks, or is ill-fitting. Purchasing the proper toilet seat for your toilet may not be the most important purchase you will ever make for your home but it is definitely at the top of the list.

The three popular, highly rated toilet seats reviewed above are all made from reputable companies that are known for strength, quality, and versatility. They are universal, meaning they fit all brands of regular toilets in Canada and the United States.

Below we have added an informative buying guide so we can provide help by outlining the important options and considerations to look at when sorting through all the different toilet seats. This guide and the helpful reviews above will make choosing a toilet seat super easy.

Best Toilet Seat Buying Guide

There are several things you want to think about before you purchase your toilet seat. These questions will help you narrow down your choices so you can find the right one for your specific needs.

  • What bathroom is the toilet seat for, the Master, kids’ bathroom, guest bathroom? The bathroom the seat is going into will determine some of the features you may want to get such as a built-in nightlight for the kids’ bathroom or an auto air freshener for the guest bathroom.
  • Do you want a fancier bathroom with a spa-like atmosphere? Choose options like cleansing seats, bidet seats and other similar features.
  • What style is the bathroom you are installing the seat in? Of course, the toilet seat is not usually the focus of the bathroom you can definitely choose a seat that can hold its own when it comes to style. Look for seats that come in different colors that you can coordinate, shapes that match the style of the room and more.
  • If you have small children that are getting ready to hit the potty training age you can look for seats that work well for both adults and toddlers who are just learning to use the bathroom. This well-designed style of toilet seat makes toddler potty training easier on the whole family.
  • Choose the right shape seat to match your toilet. This will ensure that the fit is correct and the seat will operate properly and look good too. Make sure that you have the right shape by measuring your existing seat from the hinge bolt in the back to the very front of the seat.

  • Distinguishing the Good from the Bad

    Not all toilet seats are equal! There are seats that are good and there are bad ones out there as well so it is up to you to get the knowledge you need to be able to tell the difference.

  • Bad Toilet Seats – How do you know a toilet seat is bad? Some of the earmarks of a bad toilet seat are going to be super inexpensive cost, not comfortable, made of cheap materials. If you are looking for a toilet seat for a bathroom that is barely used, purchasing a “bad” toilet seat is okay but if it is going to be used regularly, you do not want to waste your money. A bad toilet seat will range from $10 to $20 dollars. Some can even be as low as $6 or $7 dollars.
  • Good Toilet Seats – Right off the bat you will notice that a good toilet seat will be made of strong, solid materials like solid wood or hard plastic. The materials are typically heavier and they FEEL sturdier. The hinges on good toilet seats will be made of high-quality hardware and will offer better seat support where the seat comes in contact with the toilet bowl itself. Mounting hardware is usually better although this is not always the case. Some really good toilets have cheap hardware but this can be replaced with hardware that is sturdy and strong. Good toilet seats will usually have 4 bumpers supports to distribute weight evenly over the four bumpers to prevent toilet seats that shift around.

  • Toilet Seat Sizes

    There are two different sizes of toilet seats available for bathrooms. These two sizes are round and elongated. If you do not choose the right size for your existing toilet it will not fit. For the most part, toilet seats are the same except an elongated one is longer than the round.

    This is not taking into account the different options and features that toilet seats can have now. To find out which toilet bowl you have measuring the existing toilet seat from the hinges in the back to the very front of the seat. Once you know whether you have a round or elongated model, you can then look for different options, features, colors, and more.

    Common Toilet Seat Features

    There are many different features and options that you will be able to choose from when you start toilet seat shopping. The features below are almost always available for both round and elongated toilet seats. Look at the different features and see which ones appeal to you. Consider the ones that you know you will use and not just the trendy, flash-in-the-pan features.

  • Quiet-Close Seats – Quiet-close, whisper-close, and soft-close are all terms used to describe this type of toilet seat. They are designed not to slam down hard onto the toilet and close slowly with just a touch. They are great choices for households with small children.
  • Quick Removal – This feature allows for quick and easy removal of the toilet seat. The benefit to this feature is that it makes deep cleaning the toilet very easy since you can quickly remove the seat, clean the whole bowl and then put the seat back on in a matter of minutes.
  • Easy Install – No one wants to struggle with installing a toilet seat or have to pay a ridiculous amount to a professional to have it done. Easy install seats allow the toilet seat to be attached to the bowl quickly and easily without special tools or taking more than a few minutes.
  • Secure Fit – This feature is designed to prevent the seat from sliding around when you are using it. It is also typically ergonomically designed to be comfortable for the whole family. The seat is held in place with rubber bumpers that are on the bottom of the seat. 4 bumper seats are more secure than two.
  • Cleansing Seats – Cleansing toilet seats offer bidet style functions that are a great addition to using toilet paper. Some people love bidet style seats so if this is your preference you can get the spa like bidet style without having to have a whole bidet installed.
  • Deodorizing Seats – Some toilets offer a feature that includes a carbon filter that will get rid of odors that can make your bathroom smell bad. Kohler is one such company that offers deodorizing toilet seats. Some are made with a fan and scented packs that will fill the bathroom with a pleasing scent. Great for guest bathrooms.
  • Lighted Seats – This is a very cool feature if you have children or you get up frequently during the night to use the bathroom and hate the blinding light glaring into your eyes when you are not even fully awake. Many toilet seats that have a lighted feature have a nightlight that is built right in and can come in a variety of soft colors.
  • Color Choices – The most common color for toilets is of course, white but that doesn’t mean that is your only choice. Toilet seats can come in a huge variety of colors that can match your toilet bowl and bathroom, or complement it. It usually looks better to match the toilet seat to the bowl itself.

  • Conclusion

    Despite all the features and options, choosing the right toilet seat does not have to be an overly complicated ordeal. Use the information in this guide to help you sort through the different seat options and features after you determine what you are looking for.

    Don’t forget to take a look at the three top-rated toilet seats we reviewed for you. These high-quality seats will be perfect for any bathroom and will provide quality, style, and durability too.